South African government says appeal coming in Semenya case

South Africa's Caster Semenya competes to win the gold in the women's 800-meter final during the Diamond League in Doha, Qatar, Friday, May 3, 2019. (AP Photo/Kamran Jebreili)

South African government says there will be an appeal against Caster Semenya ruling

South Africa's track federation will appeal against the Caster Semenya ruling, the country's sports ministry said Monday.

The government ministry said two of the three judges who heard the case at the Court of Arbitration for Sport were "conflicted," facts were ignored and track and field's governing body was given "unfettered latitude" to do as it pleases.

Athletics South Africa, the governing body of track and field in the country, was one of two parties alongside Semenya to take the IAAF to court to challenge its testosterone regulations in female competitions.

The IAAF won the case and last week rules came into effect requiring the Olympic 800-meter champion from South Africa and other female athletes with "differences of sex development" conditions and high levels of natural testosterone to medically lower them to be eligible to compete in events from 400 meters to one mile.

At a Diamond League track meet in Qatar two days after losing the case, Semenya said she would not take medication and follow the rules.

Athletics South Africa declined to comment Monday on any appeal and Semenya's lawyers have also not confirmed any appeal.

Still, sports ministry spokesman Vuyo Mhaga insisted that ASA made the decision to appeal and the ministry had merely been informed by ASA of the move.

Parties can appeal a CAS decision on a very limited number of grounds. They include a lack of jurisdiction, a violation of procedural rules, or a ruling that's incompatible with public policy. An appeal would be heard by the Swiss Federal Tribunal.

In its statement, the South African sports ministry outlined ASA's grounds for an appeal.

It said two of the three judges who heard the Semenya case were "conflicted" because they sat on a case involving the IAAF's previous testosterone regulations brought by Indian sprinter Dutee Chand in 2015.

Semenya lost her case by a 2-1 majority ruling of the panel.

The sports ministry also said the scientific and medical evidence presented by Semenya's lawyers was strong yet "the facts before court and the outcome do not match."

The ministry said the CAS decision did not fully address how the IAAF would implement the contentious hormone limits, which have been described as ethically questionable by the World Medical Association.

"The pertinent legal questions that the court should have addressed were not addressed," the South African sports ministry said. "The court simply gave the unfettered latitude to the IAAF to do as it pleases."

___

More AP sports: https://apnews.com/apf-sports and https://twitter.com/AP_Sports

Related News

Young US archer Zach Garrett hits target on and off field

Aug 10, 2016

There's another showdown looming between well-known Americans in the men's archery tournament

Prince Fielder emotional as he ends career after surgeries

Aug 11, 2016

Prince Fielder says it will be tough not be able to play again after having to walk away from the game because of health issues after two cervical fusions in his neck

Top of the charts: Anthony now top scorer in US history

Aug 11, 2016

Carmelo Anthony scored 31 points and became the leading scorer in U.S. Olympic history in Wednesday night's tough win over Australia

Sukan360 is a proud Malaysian Sports website enthusiastic in our local players and bring Malaysian sports news first and foremost.

Contact us: sales@sukan360.com

Soccer Racing Shootings Golf Sports Governance Men's Sports Women's Sports Press Releases